The Good & Bad Credit Divide: 5 Cities Where Residents Face Largest Credit Score Differences

Share this

Which class would you consider yourself a part of? Most people in America are in the middle class. Fewer people are poor, and an even smaller number are part of the elite rich class.

Your credit score follows the same pattern. Exactly two-thirds of Credit Sesame members have good credit scores (66.7%; 759 – 551) and 23.4% have poor credit scores (550 or less). Members with excellent credit scores (760 or above) make up the smallest category at 9.9%.

In some cities around the nation, however, credit score distribution is turned on its head: fewer people are in the middle credit class and have either worked their way up into the excellent credit class, or have been downgraded into the poor credit class.

We call these “credit gap” cities because there is a great divide between the credit-poor masses and the smaller population of credit-rich, with a smaller number of consumers in the middle.

What is a credit gap?

A credit gap is, essentially, the number of people with credit scores in the middle of the range. A city with a large number of consumers in the middle has a small credit gap. Most consumers, in other words, do alright, credit-wise. A stratified credit society (in which a large number of consumers are on the top or the bottom of the scale) has a small credit gap. For Credit Sesame members nationwide, most consumers, about 67%, are in the middle (551 – 759). That proportion changes in certain communities, and we wondered why.

Small credit gaps – where more people are credit-rich or credit-poor – can be caused by many different factors, such as the presence of a high proportion of wealthy elites, loss of major employers (and hence a heavier reliance on credit), a heavy emphasis on community-wide financial literacy, and others.

We were curious: what causes credit gaps to form, and what do these cities look like? We dived into the top five cities with the smallest credit gaps in America to find out.

1. San Francisco, California

Credit gap: 53.4%


Gentrification affects many parts of America, notably including San Francisco. The current tech boom attracts legions of young, high-salary employees to the Bay area. On the surface that sounds great, but things don’t look so rosy when you consider some of the ramifications. Median housing values have skyrocketed to $1,132,300, forcing many average workers out of the area.

San Francisco’s credit profile shows a clearly shrinking credit middle class: 38.2% of residents have excellent credit (and presumably high incomes), and only 8.2% of residents have poor credit.

2. Detroit, Michigan

Credit gap: 55.1%

Detroit, MI | http://bit.ly/2iikp4F
Detroit, MI | http://bit.ly/2iikp4F

Detroit has seen better days, and the city is in the midst of a long-term revitalization with a diversified approach. Many residents remain from Detroit’s manufacturing glory days and continue to struggle economically. Economic struggles often translate to credit struggles.

Only 13.5% of residents possess a bachelor’s degree or higher, which in turn hurts their job and income prospects. The median household income for Detroit residents is just $25,764, less than half of the nationwide median household income of $53,889.

Few financial literacy programs are available in Detroit, and when financial illiteracy is combined with low income, you’ve got a double whammy that results in a poor credit score for a whopping 42.8% of residents.

3. Washington, D.C.

Credit gap: 57.9%

Washington D.C. | http://bit.ly/2hOoSby
Washington D.C. | http://bit.ly/2hOoSby

You might imagine senators, librarians and museum caretakers when you think of Washington D.C. but that picture represents only part of the truth. People in Washington D.C. are the most educated of all the city residents on our list—nearly twice as many people possess a bachelor’s degree or higher in Washington D.C. as the rest of the nation (54.6% vs. 29.8%).

Although smart people can still make dumb financial mistakes, it would stand to reason that higher education and higher incomes translate into higher credit scores here. Credit scores follow a similar pattern as education levels—nearly twice as many people have excellent credit in Washington D.C. when compared with the rest of the nation (17.0% vs. 9.9%). Now if only we could get all those government officials to put that brainpower towards working together!

4. New York, New York

Credit gap: 59.4%

New York, New York | http://bit.ly/2hxahoV
New York, New York | http://bit.ly/2hxahoV

The Big Apple’s population is diverse in every way, including financial profiles. Although NYC is home to plenty of millionaires and billionaires, New York as a whole doesn’t look too different than the rest of the country when we look at income: the $53,373 median household income is right in line with the nation ($53,889).

Residents of New York do differ in their credit profiles, however—where only 9.9% of Credit Sesame members nationwide have excellent credit scores, 15.7% of New York residents are in this upper tier.

The key takeaway: you don’t have to have a high income to have a high credit score. Even though residents of New York earn the same as the rest of us, they are nearly twice as likely to have a higher credit score. It just goes to show that it’s not the size of your income that matters. It’s how you use it.

5. Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Credit gap: 59.5%

Milwaukee, MI | https://flic.kr/p/6WzRCv
Milwaukee, MI | https://flic.kr/p/6WzRCv

Milwaukee is perched on the picturesque shores of Lake Michigan, a location that served the city well when it exported manufactured goods back in its heyday. Nowadays Milwaukee is struggling to find its economic niche as it restructures and moves away from a heavy manufacturing base to a more diversified economy that will withstand the test of time.

Unfortunately, many of the residents of Milwaukee were hurt financially through the deindustrialization process. Less than a quarter of Milwaukee residents hold bachelor’s degrees or higher (23%). Lower education levels make it harder to land good non-manufacturing jobs.

The $35,958 median household income for the city is lower than the national average. That could lead to financial struggles and greater reliance on credit. Only 5.0% of Milwaukee residents manage their credit well enough to hold excellent credit scores.


We identified cities of at least 1,000 Credit Sesame members and ranked them by the smallest percentage of people with good (759 – 551) credit.

Median household income and percent of residents with bachelor’s level college degrees or higher was collected from the U.S. Census Bureau 2015 data.

See your score.
Reach your goals

Begin your financial journey with Credit Sesame today.  Get your FREE credit score in seconds.

By clicking on the button above, you agree to the Credit Sesame Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

See your score.
Reach your goals.

Begin your financial journey with Credit Sesame today.
Get your FREE credit score in seconds.

By clicking on the button above, you agree to the Credit Sesame Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Advertiser Disclosure

Many of the offers that appear on this site are from companies from which Credit Sesame receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear (including, for example, the order in which they appear). Credit Sesame provides a variety of offers, but these offers do not include all financial services companies or all products available.

Credit Sesame is an independent comparison service provider. Reasonable efforts have been made to maintain accurate information throughout our website, mobile apps, and communication methods; however, all information is presented without warranty or guarantee. All images and trademarks are the property of their respective owners.